Category: Full Episode

Ep 291: Reconsidered: 37 – Sherri Papini Original Airdate: 01/26/21 It’s been over four years since 34 year old mother Sherri Papini…

Ep 290: After a Tinder romance turned out to be the most infamous scam of the digital age, one woman turned her…

Ep 289: Reconsidered: 36 – Wendy Trapaga Original Airdate: 01/12/21 Four days after her wedding, this beautiful, loving, young 21-year-old newlywed, was…

Ep 288: She was a beloved university advisor. He was a retired detective. They were the perfect couple—until one morning, everything shattered.…

Ep 287: Reconsidered: 35 – Patricia Stallings and Interview with Jessica Henry Original Airdate: 12/15/20 After her three month old son Ryan…

Ep 286: Instead of protection, this domestic violence survivor was sentenced to twenty years in prison. Was it justice, or a system…

Ep 285: Reconsidered: 34 – Virginia McMartin Original Airdate: 12/01/20 In the 1980s a prominent 76-year-old owner of a family-run preschool was…

Ep 284: In 1988, an 8-year-old girl disappeared off of Hogan Avenue in Fort Wayne, Indiana. It would take 30 years for…

Ep 283: Reconsidered: 33 – Marshae Jones Original Airdate: 11/24/20 27-year-old, Marshae Jones was five months pregnant when she was involved in…

Ep 282: A brilliant chemist disappears, but the clues that lead-investigators to her body don’t solve the case This is the Geetha…

Ep 281: Reconsidered: 32 – Cindy James Original Airdate: 11/17/20 During the 1980s, Cindy James was purportedly the victim of over 100…

Ep 280: Was Missouri’s longest-serving female prisoner a murderer… or a scapegoat of sexism and tunnel vision? This is the Patty Prewitt…